Study: SD Freedom Caucus members among most ineffective in passing legislation in Pierre
A reader shared an interesting study they did this weekend, and thought it might be worthwhile to share with Dakotawarcollege.com readers. They took a good hard look at the freedom caucus’ legislative record. And if you take a good hard look, it’s not so good.
I was wondering how effective the eight Freedom Caucus members were in getting their prime-sponsored bills passed into law compared to all other Republicans. So I did an analysis. No ideology – just looking at data. The difference is stark:
Legislative Effectiveness — Republicans Only – 2025 South Dakota Legislative Session:
Purpose – To compare legislative effectiveness of Republican Freedom Caucus legislators to all other Republican legislators using a single, objective metric: how often a legislator’s own bills (prime-sponsored) became law. This memo evaluates outcomes only and does not assess ideology, rhetoric, or intent.
Method:
• Legislature: 105 members
• Republicans: 95
• Freedom Caucus Republicans analyzed: 8
• Non–Freedom-Caucus Republicans: 87Metric:
• Prime sponsor only
• “Win” = bill signed into law
• Excludes resolutions, commemorations, and cosponsorshipsFreedom Caucus Members — Prime Sponsor Results
Member Prime Bills Signed Win % John Carley 12 2 16.7% Phil Jensen 6 0 0.0% Logan Manhart 4 2 50.0% Tina Mulally 6 1 16.7% Aaron Aylward 10 2 20.0% Heather Baxter 9 1 11.1% Dylan Jordan 6 0 0.0% Tony Randolph 6 0 0.0% Freedom Caucus totals:
• Prime bills: 59
• Signed into law: 8
• Win rate: 13.6%
• Bills passed per member: 1.0Prime-Sponsor Performance — Republicans Only
Group Members Prime Bills Signed Win % Bills Passed per Member Freedom Caucus Republicans 8 59 8 13.6% 1.0 Non-FC Republicans 87 371 180 48.5% 2.07 Key Takeaways
• Freedom Caucus Republicans passed about one out of every seven bills they sponsored.
• Non-Freedom Caucus Republicans passed nearly half of the bills they sponsored.Bottom Line:
In the 2025 session, Freedom Caucus Republicans passed 13.6% of their prime-sponsored bills. Non-Freedom Caucus Republicans passed 48.5% of their bills.
Not exactly a bell-ringing endorsement for a group that likes to send out press releases making demands of the administration and of other Republicans on how to conduct the business of government.





After pleading “No Contest” and receiving a suspended imposition of sentence 




advertisers to get their message out to “those in the know” of South Dakota politics and and community opinion leaders as we count the days until the next legislative session!